Posted by
Ray Py on Thursday, February 26, 2009 12:00:52 AM
Wednesday, February 25, 2009
Life as a journalist was one controlled adventure after another. I loved every minute of it. I remember being in a newsroom when excitingand historical events occurred and when others would ask, years later “do you remember where you were when such and such occurred?
And my answer would be “That’s easy. I was in a newsroom.”
For instance I was in a newsroom when bells on the Associate Press machine suddenly banged with the terse statement that President Kennedy had been shot in Dallas. It prompted my first and only call to a press room to “stop the press!”
Now there is a story I am familiar with that appears every so often on an internet web site called Websleuths, about an unsolved murder 46 years ago. I was on the scene when Florence Kilsdonk, 28, was found slashed with nine knife cuts and dead under a kitchen table. On top of the table, her infant son, Jeffery, in diaper and a shirt, but safe. He had been the only witness to his mother’s murder.
The case has gone unsolved from that day, Dec. 18, 1963 to the present time and a special task force of the Outagamie County Sheriff’s Department in northern Wisconsin where I was working at the time, is studying the crime as a cold case.
In that long ago day, crime investigation was almost like playing at cops and robbers. Very little sophistication as far as investigating techniques were available to many police agencies, much less those rural agencies where crimes were often solved by veteran investigators who relied more on “gut feeling” to solve crimes than on new fangled technologies.
The press was considered an ally of law enforcement and helpful to many investigations. That’s why crime scenes were open to reporters and most officers were not reluctant to talk officially or unofficially with reporters during the course of an investigation.
In such an environment, reporters were often in squad cars when police were called to a crime scene. That’s where I was when I arrived with the sheriff at the Kilsdonk crime scene in Black Creek, a small village in northern Wisconsin. I spent more than two hours with him as he and others on his staff as they tried to make sense of the murder before them.
I was free to wander the scene, pick up items, use the telephone, snoop into closets and bedrooms on my own, produce a photograph of the murdered woman, compare my notes with investigators’ notes.
Today a reporter would not be able to penetrate within a mile of a crime scene much less wander as free as I did among the clues, overhear conversations, take notes or ask questions. It is an era gone and probably good riddance.
The story I wrote on Dec. 19, the day following the murder, is printed now on a website and its facts still stand up. Today, in re-reading the account, I am pleased with the job I did.
But it was tabloid and yellow journalism. Newspapers thrived on it and readers could not get enough.
The facts were these: Florence was knifed about 8 a.m.as she sat at the kitchen table shucking peanuts with her small baby in a baby seat near her on the table.
The woman struggled with someone who apparently entered the house from an unlocked back door. She fell dead under the table.
Her body was discovered by her husband, Marvin, 29, who came home from work, discovered the scene, apparently got some blood on his hands, grabbed the baby blanket near his child in an attempt to determine if the child was safe, then turned and ran from house without the child, took his car and drove to a neighbor who he asked to call the police. He left a bloody handprint on the blanket.
Marvin passed a lie detector exam about his involvement in the crime but was a suspect, at least in the sheriff’s mind, for many years. His “gut feeling” was the fact that Marvin had left the baby to run for help, but had no knowledge that the killer may still be in the house and the child still in danger. No father would do that, the sheriff told me.
But there never were charges and the Kilsdonk killing heads a list of 16 other unsolved murders in the northern area of Wisconsin, unsolved since 1963.
As cold case investigators go over 46 year old reports since in the open case file with the sheriff’s department, Marvin has gown to an old man, is a resident of a nursing home and, when asked about the case hopes it can still be solved.